Art Beyond Borders

Dec 29, 2016
Okay, India did not call Pakistani artists to Bollywood, they came by their own choice. But does that mean they came illegally? Like Salman Khan quoted, Pakistani artists came to India with permission and VISA issued by Government of India.

The burning disputes among two South Asian nations, be it for any reason has been affecting entire South Asian countries at present. Cancellation of SAARC summit could be given as prime example about how entire SAARC had impact. Apart, the burning tension among two nations is equally troubling other nations regarding the side to be taken. This political clash among two nations led to hatred among two nations, and after Indian Motion Picture Producer Association on Thursday passed a resolution on banning Pakistani artists and technicians from Bollywood industry - the internal clash appeared on the wider screen.

Today, Americans don't care their political relationship with China while using any Chinese products, nor do Chinese think twice before buying American innovation. Movies are forms of art that express individual thought and feeling achieved through the creative process. Art connects human beings to each other and allows in expressing relationship to the world around them. Movies are forms of art, which are an independent entity; totally away from political moves.

Bollywood is the centre of for movies in entire Asia. The number of movies made, revenue granted to Government annually and the profit generated out of movies must be enough to illustrate the entire picture of its strength. While Medias are regarded as fourth part of Indian body, cricket fifth, it is Bollywood that has been regarded sixth part of Indian body.

This multi-billion dollar business is no longer associated with India - as it has been bringing impact throughout South Asia and different other parts of the world too. Apart from it, Bollywood has proved itself to be the hub of intelligent, skilled, professional and experts. From Nepalese artists like Udit Narayan Jha to Afghan artists like Kadar Khan;  or be it Jacqueline Fernandez of Sri Lanka to Nargis Fakhri of America - they have been doing their best to make Bollywood more qualitative and worthy. Also, the world wide release and earning from other nations excluding India has proved Bollywood bigger than Indian territory. The craze of Bachhan is not limited within India, as my family always turns out eager to see him in television in Nepal. Be it in local buses of Kathmandu, or pubs in Pokhara of Nepal, there are Bollywood tracks being played indicating Bollywood has something to do far beyond India too.

Now, the decision taken by IMPPA appeared as if every Pakistani citizen is a terrorist - be it some kid going to school, or some actor performing in movies. The world is against terrorism, it is understandable, but how can state be rude towards citizen of different nation? Does this mean - if conflict between China and India pops out - every Indian from China should be kicked out? Article 2 of Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) clearly states that no discrimination shall be made to anyone of any sovereignty. There have been diplomatic issues between several nations, also between Nepal and India in the last year, but none of the artists spoke anything making political remarks. Artists have their own tasks to perform - they are not terrorists. Hollywood probably will never boycott Priyanka Chopra just because she is an Indian for any political reason.
Insult of Pakistani actors in India led to ban of Bollywood movies in Pakistan. Islamabad has banned broadcasting of Indian TV Channels in Pakistan instructing strict actions to be taken if any operator does not implement this after October 15. Pakistan certainly used to be small but it is the good market for Bollywood industry. I won't be wrong if I said - Pakistanis were more interested in Bollywood than South Indians. This small market seems to be at stake right now, and probably a loss, be it for short term. It's Indian movie industry who will have to suffer in the long run. Maybe, after Bollywood actors realized this - they condemned the decision. Bollywood experts have regarded these Pakistani celebs as 'jewel' to the industry after all, and their returning back will certainly bring impact. For short term, the movies where they had role will have to suffer, and for long term Bollywood industry might lose these jewels. Ban of Indian channels on the other hand, will certainly bring loss to Pakistan as well.

There are diplomatic relations, and there can be misunderstandings and conflict among the nations. Nepal too had diplomatic issue with India last year. The heated blood within Nepalese tried to boycott Indian movies too, but state never provoked in it. Despite the hatred among Nepalese towards Indian policy, people had been playing Bollywood tracks in shops, buses, cafes and pubs as well. It was an art that was appreciated, despite short-term hatred, creativity; innovation was always appreciated by general people throughout the country. Maybe, that was the reason - people even watched Bollywood movies during that time, did not miss any good Hindi numbers.

What does general public want? It is the prime question. Does Bollywood audience really want to ignore Pakistani artists? Or, does Pakistani audience really don't want to see Indian channels in Pakistan? State had to play key role before implementation of any decision. Patriotism is good, in fact very good; but patriotism cannot be practised by hurting ego of others. Patriotism should not guide to hate others in the name of loving ourselves.

Art field like cinemas, music should rather be imposed for unification more than division. Unlike cricket, art is not anything competitive where one has to be defeated. Movies and music unite people and make them stand with one strong position. They should be kept aloof from political issues. Apart, every Pakistanis should not be termed terrorists - and the number of deaths of innocents in Pakistan should also be analyzed. Both world wars came to an end through peaceful agreement. Sooner or later, both India and Pakistan should come to some concrete decisions. Hence, it is important for everyone to play role from their point at this time. Media should be sensitive and rather than provoking war, should seek ways to find mutual agreements. Every individual needs to understand that policy and person are two different aspects.

We all are against terrorism. The world is against terrorism. But - for these reasons it's unwise to see every individual differently. While the economic blockade imposed by India on Nepal, I was in India and while the hatred among two nations was getting global perspective, I was in India, living with full dignity. No one told me to return back. Should I now fear - if anything as such happens again - I will be told to return back? India is a big democratic nation and should have understood these principles of democracy and freedom.

It is important to respect every individual. And we hope Pakistani celebrities will be called back sooner to Bollywood industry and would be granted the required respect. It could be something stupid to imagine arts - being biased to ethnicity, religion, culture. An art does not have any boundary.


Published in Annapurna Post's English Edition of Nov 16, 2016



No comments: